The 2026 MLB season is barely a quarter of the way through, yet the Rookie of the Year (ROY) race is already heating up. The latest ROY poll reveals a dramatic shakeup in both leagues, with new contenders rising and previous favorites falling. This season's ROY candidates are proving to be a fascinating bunch, each bringing their own unique skills and stories to the table.
In the American League, McGonigle has surged to the top, riding a wave of success with a .333 average and a .929 OPS over his past 11 games. His .291 average and .394 on-base percentage for the season are the best among AL rookies with at least 200 plate appearances. McGonigle's 101 total bases are tied for second-most among all AL rookies, showcasing his all-around talent. Meanwhile, Murakami, a lefty slugger, has been a force to be reckoned with, leading all MLB rookies with 20 homers and a .938 OPS. His 41 RBIs entering play Monday further solidify his ROY credentials.
The National League is no less exciting. Wetherholt, the Cardinals' top prospect, has made a strong case for himself with a .358 on-base percentage and a .753 OPS. His nine homers are second-most among NL rookies, and his performance over the past seven games has been impressive. Stewart, another standout, leads all NL rookies with 12 homers, 39 RBIs, and an .801 OPS. His 25 extra-base hits and a 15.2 percent barrel rate in May further highlight his power and skill.
The poll also showcases the rise of lesser-known prospects. Messick, a lefty, has been a dominant force for the Guardians, leading AL rookies in wins, innings, and strikeouts. Bazzana, another Guardian, has adjusted well to the bigs, hitting .304 with an .841 OPS since May 13. Tolle, a lefty, has impressed with a 2.28 ERA and a .192 opponents' average, allowing two earned runs or fewer in six of his eight starts.
In the NL, Griffin, who also placed fourth in the first ROY poll, was sidelined by a forearm strain but had been heating up before the injury. Benge, a late bloomer, has come on strong in June, raising his season OPS by 51 percentage points. These players' stories and performances showcase the depth of talent in this year's rookie class.
As the season progresses, the ROY race will continue to evolve, with new challenges and surprises. The poll results provide a snapshot of the current landscape, but the final outcome will depend on how these young players continue to develop and perform. The 2026 ROY contenders are a fascinating bunch, and their journeys will undoubtedly keep fans engaged and excited throughout the season.
